Tempering Chocolate Troubleshooting
Tips and tricks help with the most common chocolate tempering problems
Working with chocolate can be incredibly frustrating, and no one knows that better than us! It’s temperamental, literally. It’s extremely sensitive to changes in temperature, humidity/moisture, agitation, etc. etc.! You think everything is going your way, and you're tempering chocolate correctly, and then you realize things have gone terribly wrong.
For a quick reminder about what tempering is, why we have to temper chocolate, and how to temper chocolate click here.
Tempering chocolate is the most important skill for a chocolatier or chocolate maker. It’s likely something that you will have to practice many times before you are successful. Once you have the money to invest in your business or hobby, you will likely buy a tempering machine that will make your life infinitely easier. BUT, having said machine doesn’t mean that you don’t have to learn how to temper. Learning how to temper chocolate is not only about the outcome. It’s about making sure that you understand the process – the chemistry involved, the steps involved, what you’re looking for, and why.
Tips for troubleshooting chocolate tempering
With that said, there are some common issues that may explain why your chocolate isn’t tempering properly.
Control your work room air temperature and humidity
If it was warmer or cooler in the room during your practice session, then you will have to adjust for the change in room temperature in how you temper. For example, the amount of seed needed in the seeding method; reduction of the temperature by making the cool water bath or marble slab a little colder; keeping the warm water bath stable when you try to maintain the temper. Too much humidity or too dry a climate also can affect temper. Yes, air conditioning and humidity control will be vital for your commercial operation. The ideal kitchen or production space temperature for working with chocolate is 64 -70°F (18 - 21°C) and 50 - 65% humidity.
Check your thermometer
As you are checking very minuscule temperature changes from one degree to the next, you need to make sure your equipment is used properly and functioning correctly. You will want to take the temperature after stirring the chocolate mass thoroughly (not when it has been sitting for a while, as a thick mass will develop hot and cool spots).
Keep stirring/agitating the chocolate mass as you temper
Did you continually stir the mass throughout the process? If you leave it on the slab or in the bowl without stirring, you run the risk of the part of the mass that is up against the cool marble slab solidifying. Or the chocolate up against the hot bottom of the bowl falling out of temper because it gets too hot. Again, since we are talking about differences of only one or two degrees, you have to be careful with the process.
Be careful about introducing bubbles of air into your chocolate mass
Stir or agitate carefully with a pull or push, not a whipping motion, so you don't introduce air, which will cause air bubbles to form. These bubbles can be a big problem when you are molding. And be aware that air bubbles happen more readily if you are tempering a non-couverture chocolate i.e. one with a higher viscosity. Always research the viscosity of the chocolate you are using so you know if it will work better for ganache (more viscous) or better for enrobing/molding (more fluid).
Don't over-temper or over-seed your mass of chocolate
As you stir the chocolate mass over time at the working temperature, you create more V-form crystals which makes the chocolate mass thicker until it's hard to work with, even though it's still in temper. To combat this you need to melt some of the excess V-form crystals by either:
- the addition of warm chocolate at 115° F (47° C). Be careful not to raise the temperature of the whole mass too much as you do this because that will throw the chocolate out of temper.
- or heating the edges of the chocolate mass with a heat gun or over hot water. Make sure you thoroughly mix the warmed chocolate into the mass.
Are you beginning to see what we mean when we say that chocolate is temperamental? Just wait, there’s more!
Don't shock your chocolate (it doesn't like to be surprised)!
Fat bloom can occur when the center you are enrobing is too cold or has moisture on it. It can also occur from putting the enrobed centers into the fridge too long where, again, cold and moisture can promote fat or sugar bloom.
Do a temper test
Before using the mass of tempered chocolate for enrobing or molding, place a small blob of tempered chocolate on a utensil, parchment or acetate - it should harden within minutes. Also as you are working with the chocolate during your enrobing or molding session, don't forget to agitate the tempered chocolate mass and do another temper test periodically.
Ok, you’ve finished an unsuccessful tempering session, now what do you do with a mass of untempered chocolate?
You can re-temper the chocolate over and over again. The only downside is increased viscosity, IF (and that is a big IF) in an earlier session you haven't overheated the chocolate to the point of possibly burning and IF you haven't gotten any foreign substance in it, such as water, ganache or nut bits. If you think the mass was compromised in any way, start your next tempering session with new chocolate. You can use the compromised mass for recipes such as ganache or truffle centers so it isn't wasted.
When you're finished working, pour out the tempered chocolate onto parchment or acetate and let it harden for storage. One of our students pours her excess tempered chocolate into a plastic zipped storage bag, seals the top then flattens it out to harden. The flat shape is very easy to store and when you need it, you simply break up in pieces in the bag then pour back into your tempering machine or bowl to melt.
Why does the mass sometimes harden with bloom when the chocolate was tempered?
A large mass of tempered chocolate can become untempered when the heat from the center of the mass can't dissipate as you aren't agitating it anymore. So it retains the heat in the center and cools slowly. This is due to the latent heat of crystallization. As chocolate is crystallizing it gives off heat (an exothermic reaction) and can get warm enough to throw itself out of temper. This issue with latent heat is also why it is important to cool pieces when they are rapidly crystallizing. Putting your mold, or your dipped piece, into a well ventilated refrigerator as soon as you see signs of it starting to crystallize around the edges for 15 minutes or so will carry off that latent heat and prevent the pieces from throwing themselves or each other out of temper.
In that slow process of cooling, some of the cocoa butter molecules release and rise to the surface or get trapped in layers. Don't worry if this happens. You are going to have to heat the mass again to either temper it or use it in a recipe. This will mix the cocoa butter back into the mass.
When you remelt untempered chocolate to temper it again, you need to melt all the unstable crystals that were formed and solidified. Heat the mass of untempered chocolate to at least 115° F (46° C) for dark chocolate and to 110° F (44° C) for milk or white chocolate.
Note that a slight hint of bloom can also happen if you are molding very thick bars, suckers or 3D shapes and don't cool them quickly. The molded side will be fine, shiny and tempered. But the exposed part of the chocolate may have very light rings or speckles – which may or may not be a problem for you. You can overcome this problem by experimenting with using layers of chocolate to fill the mold instead of just one pour.
Absolutely Important Note: Please check the chocolate manufacturer's tempering specifications for the chocolate you are using. You can find that information on the package and/or on the manufacturer's website.
We hope these tips and tricks will help you with any challenges you’re facing when you’re tempering chocolate.
Want to learn more about making delicious chocolates and confections? Check out our Professional Chocolatier Program!
Get reminders about upcoming classes! To receive program updates and news, click the link below.